Skip to main content

Review of Karen Brown's The Longings of Wayward Girls


In this novel, Karen Brown meditates on the suffering that goes along with love and lust. This is her debut as a novelist, but Publishers Weekly named her Little Sinners and Other Stories as a Best Book of 2012.

Set in an middle class suburb near Hartford, Connecticut, The Longings of Wayward Girls is a psychological novel. The main character, Sadie Watkins, is a 36-year-old stay-at-home mother of two, and she’s
grieving her recent miscarriage. In her undone state of mind, she starts an affair with a neighbour, Ray Filley, a man she’d last seen 24 years ago.

She senses that something unseemly happened between her mother and Ray when he was a teenager, and that hunch leads Sadie on a journey toward the painful truths hidden in her fuzzy memories of summer, 1979, the year she turned thirteen: Sadie calls it “that summer” when everything changed.

Brown’s narrative structure mesmerized me in two ways:
  1. Mirroring the rift in Sadie’s memory, the chapters flip back and forth between 1979 and 2003 (the story’s current time). That structure is a hypnotic device, and it drew me in to Sadie’s world, one in which the past often seems indistinguishable from the present. I got the eerie, dreamlike feeling that the past was living itself over again;
  2. Beyond its psychological effects, the novel excels at description. Heat, thunderstorms, humidity, children's dirty feet, birds, and insects (especially cicadas) -- Brown describes these things in a way that transported me to the essence of a New England summer. And specific objects from the 1970s bring back the period, for example,
    • dixie cups;
    • ubiquitous cigarettes;
    • shag rugs in harvest gold.
These specific details drew me in and kept me in the "story world" of the novel. This is a haunting tale, one that will enchant lovers of psychological suspense.